Arizona Domestic Violence Evidence
How to start proving domestic violence in family court when there is no police report, no photos, and years of private abuse.
By Tali Best Collins, Esq. | Managing Partner, Best Law Firm
Last reviewed: July 2026
This is one of the most common things we hear from clients. You lived through years of abuse. You never called the police. You never took pictures. You were too afraid, too isolated, too exhausted, or you simply did not think anyone would believe you. And now you are sitting across from an attorney wondering if any of it even matters in a courtroom. The first thing to understand is that judges and attorneys who handle family law cases know that the absence of a police report does not mean the absence of abuse. Most domestic violence is never reported to law enforcement. Victims stay silent for every reason you can imagine — fear of retaliation, fear of not being believed, fear of what happens to the children if the abusive parent is arrested, financial dependence, shame, and the relentless message from the abusive partner that no one will believe them anyway.
This is one of the most common things we hear from clients. You lived through years of abuse. You never called the police. You never took pictures. You were too afraid, too isolated, too exhausted, or you simply did not think anyone would believe you. And now you are sitting across from an attorney wondering if any of it even matters in a courtroom.
It matters. And you can prove it. Here is how.
The first thing to understand is that judges and attorneys who handle family law cases know that the absence of a police report does not mean the absence of abuse. Most domestic violence is never reported to law enforcement. Victims stay silent for every reason you can imagine — fear of retaliation, fear of not being believed, fear of what happens to the children if the abusive parent is arrested, financial dependence, shame, and the relentless message from the abusive partner that no one will believe them anyway.
Arizona courts are required to consider all relevant evidence of domestic violence. The Alec and Lydia Act specifically says the court cannot lock out evidence of domestic violence based on when it happened or whether it was previously raised. A.R.S. § 25-403.03(E). Your history belongs in that courtroom. The question is how to organize and present it.
The single most useful thing you can do right now before you do anything else is write down what happened. Not for anyone else yet. Just for yourself. A timeline is a chronological record of the abuse in your relationship, written in your own words, in the order it happened.
A timeline does several things. It helps you remember details you may have pushed aside. It shows your attorney the scope and pattern of what happened. It demonstrates to a court that the abuse was not a single incident but a pattern of behavior over time. And it helps you feel less alone with what you went through, because when you see it written down you begin to understand the full picture of what was done to you.
Your timeline does not need to be perfect. It does not need to be in legal language. It just needs to be honest and as specific as you can make it. Here is what to include.
Do not worry about whether any single incident seems significant enough. Write it all down. Patterns matter as much as individual incidents. A court seeing twenty incidents over five years understands something very different than a court seeing one isolated event.
A timeline is the foundation. But evidence of domestic violence comes in many forms that have nothing to do with police reports or photographs.
Pulling this together feels overwhelming when you are already dealing with everything else in your life. You do not have to do it by yourself. What you need to do right now is start writing. Open a document, open a notebook, open the notes app on your phone. Start with the first thing you remember and keep going. Do not edit yourself. Do not decide what is important and what is not. Just write.
Then bring what you have written to your attorney. Your attorney’s job is to take your history and help you understand what it means legally, what evidence can be gathered, what witnesses can be called, and how to present your story in a way that a court can understand and act on.
Under the Alec and Lydia Act your full history of domestic violence is now admissible in your family court case. The history that was never told can be told. But someone has to help you tell it. That is exactly what we do.
Tali Best Collins handles every new client consultation personally at Best Law Firm. You do not need to have it figured out before you call. You need your story. That is where we start.
If domestic violence, coercive control, child safety, legal decision making, or parenting time is part of your Arizona family law case, a focused consultation can help you understand what evidence matters and what the court should now be required to consider.
The Alec and Lydia Act resource hub
Coercive control is domestic violence in Arizona
Tali Best Collins is the Managing Partner of Best Law Firm in Scottsdale, Arizona, where she and her colleagues have practiced family law exclusively for over nineteen years. She is a former Judge Pro Tem in Maricopa County Superior Court and co-author of The Divorce Coach with Cynthia L. Best, Founder of Best Law Firm. Tali handles every new client consultation personally.
Best Law Firm | 7025 N. Scottsdale Road Suite 303 | Scottsdale, AZ 85253 | (480) 219-2433 | Talk to Tali
This post is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. The Alec and Lydia Act is new law and courts are actively working through how it applies. Reading this post does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please consult a qualified Arizona family law attorney about your specific situation. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.
We can conduct your consultation by phone, zoom or in person. Call us today at (480) 219-2433 or fill out the form below.